Artificial intelligence has rapidly evolved from a futuristic concept into a practical tool used across nearly every major industry. From healthcare to finance, businesses are finding ways to automate tasks, analyze data, and improve decision-making. The legal field is no exception, particularly when it comes to the operational side of running a firm.
One area seeing significant transformation is talent acquisition. For law firms and businesses alike, finding the right candidate is often a time-consuming and resource-heavy endeavor. However, the integration of AI is changing the landscape, offering new ways to streamline recruitment while reducing costs.
Leading the conversation on this technological shift is Attorney Thomas Pivnicny, Managing Partner at Kitay Law Offices. With a background in building in-house recruiting departments and implementing AI-driven workflows, Pivnicny offers a unique perspective on how legal professionals can adapt to these changes. His insights provide a roadmap for organizations looking to modernize their hiring practices without losing the human element essential to building a strong team.
Thomas J. Pivnicny, Esq. – Managing Partner at Kitay Law Offices
At its core, artificial intelligence in hiring refers to the use of smart software to automate parts of the recruitment process. This does not mean replacing human recruiters with robots. Instead, it involves using technology to handle high-volume, repetitive tasks, allowing human decision-makers to focus on evaluating the best candidates.
Applications of AI in this sector are vast. They range from algorithms that screen resumes to chatbots that handle initial candidate questions. For example, tools like RingSense provide conversation intelligence, analyzing interactions to offer insights that humans might miss. Similarly, platforms like Case Companion by EvenUp help streamline drafting and case management, indirectly freeing up staff time to focus on growth and hiring needs.
The adoption of these tools is becoming standard in modern Human Resources departments. As the legal industry becomes more competitive, the ability to quickly identify and secure top talent is a distinct advantage. AI allows firms to move faster than traditional methods ever permitted.
Integrating AI into the hiring process offers tangible benefits that go beyond simple convenience. For organizations aiming to scale, these advantages can significantly impact the bottom line.
The most immediate benefit is efficiency. Traditional hiring involves hours of manual resume screening, often leading to bottlenecked workflows. AI tools can process hundreds of applications in minutes, identifying candidates who meet specific criteria instantly. This automation drastically speeds up the hiring timeline, reducing the “time-to-hire” metric that many HR departments struggle to improve.
Speed is valuable, but quality is paramount. AI algorithms can filter candidates based on objective data points such as skills, experience, and certifications. By focusing on these specific criteria, organizations can ensure they are interviewing applicants who are genuinely qualified for the role. When configured correctly, these tools may also help reduce unconscious bias by focusing solely on the data provided, rather than subjective factors.
Recruitment is expensive. Between advertising costs, recruiter salaries, and the time leadership spends on interviews, the expenses add up. By automating the initial stages of screening and outreach, firms can lower the costs associated with manual labor. Furthermore, optimized resource allocation means HR staff can spend their time on high-value tasks, such as employee retention and culture building, rather than administrative paperwork.
Attorney Pivnicny advocates for AI strategies to build efficient internal departments. His approach goes beyond theory, applying these tools directly to firm operations.
Effective outreach is critical in a crowded job market. Pivnicny highlights the use of AI for optimizing online display ads, ensuring they reach the right demographic at the right time. Furthermore, the use of AI voice agents, such as those powered by ElevenLabs, can handle initial candidate outreach. These tools can conduct preliminary screening calls or schedule interviews, ensuring that candidates remain engaged throughout the process without overwhelming the HR team.
In his webinars, such as “Revealing AI Communication Strategies that Work,” Pivnicny outlines how these tools function in a real-world legal setting. For instance, he successfully built an in-house Intake Department handling over 350 leads per week and a Recruiting Department responsible for multiple hires, leveraging these very technologies. Success stories from firms adopting these tools often highlight a smoother candidate experience and a more organized internal structure.
While the benefits are clear, the use of AI in hiring brings significant legal and ethical responsibilities. As a legal professional, Pivnicny emphasizes the importance of understanding the regulatory landscape.
One of the primary concerns with AI is algorithmic bias. If the historical data used to train the AI contains bias, the tool may inadvertently discriminate against certain groups of candidates. This issue was highlighted in the case of Mobley v. Workday, where the court affirmed that AI vendors could face direct liability as agents in the hiring process. This decision expands potential liability to third-party providers, making it crucial for firms to vet their tools carefully.
Firms must ensure their use of AI complies with all local and federal employment laws. This includes adhering to equal opportunity regulations and ensuring that automated decisions do not violate anti-discrimination statutes.
Best practices suggest maintaining transparency with candidates. Applicants should know if AI is being used to evaluate their application. Furthermore, maintaining a “human in the loop”—where a human recruiter reviews final decisions—is essential to ensure fairness and mitigate the risks associated with automated rejections.
AI can amplify several functions throughout the hiring and recruiting process.
Adopting new technology is rarely without hurdles. Organizations must be prepared to address specific challenges to ensure a successful implementation.
AI is only as good as the data it processes. Inaccurate or outdated data can lead to poor hiring decisions. Organizations must prioritize data hygiene, establishing strategies for cleaning and validating the information fed into their AI systems. This ensures the algorithms are working with the most accurate picture of the talent pool.
Integrating modern AI tools with legacy HR software can be difficult. Technical compatibility issues often arise, creating friction rather than efficiency. To overcome this, firms should look for AI solutions that offer robust API integrations or are specifically designed to work with their existing Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS).
Technology is useless if staff members do not know how to use it. Resistance to change is common, particularly in established firms. Overcoming this requires comprehensive training programs that empower HR staff to use AI effectively. Demonstrating how these tools make their jobs easier—rather than threatening their positions—is key to fostering adoption.
The role of AI in recruitment is set to grow. Emerging trends suggest a move toward more predictive analytics, where AI not only assesses current suitability but predicts a candidate’s long-term success and retention within a company.
As these technologies advance, the workforce will need to adapt. Continuous learning will become a necessity for HR professionals who wish to stay competitive. The future landscape of recruiting will likely be a hybrid model, where AI handles the data and logistics, and humans handle the relationships and culture fit.
Artificial intelligence offers a powerful avenue for revolutionizing the hiring process. From enhanced efficiency and cost savings to improved candidate quality, the advantages are compelling. However, as Attorney Thomas Pivnicny illustrates, these tools must be implemented with a keen awareness of the legal and ethical implications.
For those interested in diving deeper into these strategies, Attorney Pivnicny will be sharing his expertise at the upcoming AI for PI Expo in Orlando, occurring January 15-17, 2026. His presentation will cover actionable insights for law firms looking to leverage these technologies responsibly.
By balancing the speed of automation with the careful judgment of human oversight, businesses in Pennsylvania and beyond can build stronger, more capable teams ready for the future.
Fundamental legal rights are often taken for granted until they are challenged. Recently, news from…
Suffering a serious injury changes your life in an instant. Suddenly, you are facing mounting…
At Kitay Law Offices, our mission extends beyond the courtroom. For over 25 years, we…
At Kitay Law Offices, community engagement is more than just a principle; it’s a core…
Artificial intelligence is reshaping industries across the globe, and the legal field is no exception.…
The Pennsylvania legal community has another reason to be proud as Kenneth M. Kitay, founder…